Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Answering question on Fate

In the Name of Allah,

"Assalam Alaikum Adnan,


I did not comprehend the explanation to the first question at all. Please elaborate in simple words especially the second paragraph, it is very confusing?
Thanks from another struggling muslim!"

I received the above question in response to an earlier post below.

http://islamexplains.blogspot.com/2010/06/concept-of-time-fate-and-free-will.html

First of all, I am very glad that atleast one person read my email, and tried to understand it.

So, let me try to clarify my earlier explaination about Fate.

I would like to setup the background for the answer. So, Allah is the creator, which means nothing created him, and he doesn't depend upon anything. Everything else that exist is created by him. True nature of Allah cannot be understood by the creation, but he has revealed alot of information about himslef through his Messengers.

مُتَّكِـِٔينَ عَلَىٰ سُرُرٍ۬ مَّصۡفُوفَةٍ۬‌ۖ وَزَوَّجۡنَـٰهُم بِحُورٍ عِينٍ۬٠


"Reclining on ranged couches. And we wed them unto fair ones with wide, lovely eyes." (Quran 52:20)


"Praise be to Allah, the Creator of the heavens and the earth, Who appointeth the angels messengers having wings two, three and four. He multiplieth in creation what He will. Lo! Allah is Able to do all things." (35:1)


Abu Tha’labah al-Khushani said: “The Messenger of Allaah said: ‘The jinn are of three types: a types that has wings, and they fly through the air; a type that looks like snakes and dogs; and a type that stops for a rest then resumes its journey.” [Shaykh al-Albaani said in al-Mishkaat (2/1206, no. 4148): al-Tahhaawi and Abu’l-Shaykh reported it with a saheeh isnaad]

Allah created several types of creations. Some are intelligent among them. Out of the intelligent ones, there are two categories, one is created with free will, other without. Malaikaa (Angels) and Hoorin A'yn (perfectly obedient servants in Paradise) are the ones mentioned who don't have free will.  By the way, there is a misconception that Hoorayn are females. I have not seen any evidence for that. They are companions which some people translate to females. Jinnat (Deamons), and Insaan (Humans) are the ones with free will. There is also another category of creation that can only think with the permission of Allah like earth, will, on the day of judgement.

In fact, everything Allah created is Muslim, including stones, trees, sun, moon, stars, and they are created in the state of submission to Allah (Islam), and they cannot change their state. For example, stone will not walk and move to a shade. Humans and Jinn are born Muslims, because they have to disobey to become non-muslim, and they are allowed to change their state, and to disobey.

"And when thy Lord said unto the angels: Lo! I am about to place a viceroy in the earth, they said: Wilt thou place therein one who will do harm therein and will shed blood, while we, we hymn Thy praise and sanctify Thee? He said: Surely I know that which ye know not." (Quran 2:30)

Now, Angels and Hoorayn are created in the state of obedience, where they are free to think, but cannot break Allah's commands, as they are created in that fashion. For example, when Adam was created, Angels asked a question, which proves that they can think and are free to make a statement to Allah.

Jinn were created first, and dwelled the earth for a long period of time, and then Humans were created to replace Jinn on earth as leaders. Jinn are restricted to their reality, and are forbidden to intitate control over Humans in normal circumstances. That is why Iblis was mad, and our only sworn enemy, only if we understand.

So, Fate of all creations except Jinn and Humans is easy to understand, as they don't chose. Fate for Jinn and Human is the bigger question. In fact only confusion is how can we have a choice, when what we will chose is already known. No Muslim denies that Allah has knowledge of events before they occur. Question remains whether Humans and Jinns are going to be judged on something that Allah decided for us.

First of all, Allah is the most perfect Judge, and he will never punish us, if we did not chose to commit dis-obedience, freely. On the contrary, his Mercy superceeds his Anger, and he will forgive our sins, IF AND ONLY IF we repent (this is another discussion). Ah! I pitty ones that are proud on their sins, and yet expect forgiveness.

Fate is the information Allah preserved in the "Loh-e-Mahfooz", but knowing the outcome by third party doesn't remove free will. Now, if we all can read our fate, then there will be no free will. Guess what! Not knowing the future is the favour from Allah to give us a choice.

For example, if you see a man jumping from a very tall building, you can turn around and tell your friend "Man! He will die". Now, you are most likely correct, but you are not God, so your calculation could be wrong, and the person may live. Does that mean you pushed this man? NO. It just means that, with your experience, you can tell with a certainity that this person's actions are taking him to death.

So, Allah's experience is infinitely perfect, and he can predict accurately what will be the outcome of all the choices we make, but we are free to make that choice. Alternative would be that our free will depends upon him not knowing, which is not even true for humans in the above example. Knowing doesn't equate to deciding.

However, If he wanted, Allah can certainly chose for us and punish yes for something he decided, and no creation can stop him, right? But, he is kind in nature, and has created us to chose to worship him. If we chose not to worship him, and Go to club and dance with Music at the Salat against his orders, he will punish us.

Last but not least, look around you, and see how much sins humans are comitting, and even Shirk (ask help from someone other than Allah) is being allowed. This proves certainly that either Allah doesn't exist, or Allah has provided us free will. And, we know that he does exist, so we do have the free will.

Being a Muslim means to have faith in Allah, and our faith should be in Allah's Mercy that he will not punish us for something that we were not allowed to chose.

Now, stop all sinning you doing intentionally thinking you don't have free will, and become a practicing Muslim. Just Kidding!!! Do try to change though.

A struggling Muslim
Adnan

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Concept of Time, Fate, and Free Will

In the Name of Allah,

[It (the Qur'an) is a Book We have sent down to you, full of blessing, that they may ponder over its verses and that people of intelligence take heed.] (Saad 38:29)

PLEASE DO NOT READ BELOW IF YOU ARE NOT A THINKER.

Since I was a child, concept of time has always been my interest. When I read fiction and non-fiction about time-travel, it sparked many ideas and questions in my mind. In fact, I was sure that Time Travel is possible, but when I start reading Quran, I realized that Allah has already told us that some people slept for centuries in a cave, which is time travel.

Here are some of the questions.

1) If God created us and wrote our destiny, how do we have free will?
2) How was Mohammad (PBUH) able to see people in Hell and Paradise, when no one has entered yet?
3) How was Mohammad (PBUH) to travel to seventh heaven and beyond in one night?
4) How long would we be in afterlife?

All of these questions are interesting ones, there are many explaination given for them. Let me explain my point of view on these.

1) If God created us and wrote our destiny, how do we have free will?

Yes, Allah created The Pen, and told it to write everything he will create and everything about it. It includes, what all of us will do , including if we will go to Hell or Paradise. Now, on the face of this, it sounds like we don't have the free will, if our actions are known, but a deep analysis reveals that thats not true.

Allah in his infinite wisdom know everything that will happen, because if he doesn't he will not be All knowing. However, we don't know what he knows about us, or what is written. So, in the absence of that knowledge, we can keep striving for salvation.

Also, knowing what we will do doesn't mean he decided for us. For example, on your way to school, you see your friend still not ready for school, and when you reach school you tell everyone that your friend will be late today. Now, you knew that you friend will be late, but it doesn't mean your friend can blame you for making him late. Of course there is no comparison to Allah, but he has provided us free will to chose the right or wring path, otherwise it wouldn't have been fair for him to judge us.

Also, our free will is limited to our intention, but all the movements including brain sparks (thoughts) are carried by the angels. For example, if you make intention to raise your hand to scratch your face, intention is yours, but you can't move your hand unless Allah permits, and Angels make it happen. If we were to have free will in action, it would nullify many of Allah's attribute. As you remember, reward of good deeds depend upon intentions and not actions.

Next three question are connected to each other, so let's tackle them together. They are all related to our concept of time.

So, within the creation of Allah, he created a concept of progression. Everthing is progressing towards an end stage. If we think for a second, our concept of time is deduced from this progression. Earth rotating around its access gives us a day. Moon rotating around earth gives us a month and year. Our bodies growing and aging gives us life spans. Now there are some of Allah's creation where progression is very slow or different. For example, Angels are not limited to progression as we see it. In fact, they seem to go and come back through out our history without aging.

Now, everything Allah created has an end, and it will die, but some are progressing faster. I argue that concept of time in our world is even more explicit. Our universe is like a watch that was wound a long time ago, and it is winding down to its end. And, we know that there are seven firmaments (heavens) and lowest is our reality which has the slowest progression of time. It is clear in the following.

"He arranges (every) affair from the heavens to the earth, then it (affair) will go up to Him, in one Day, the space whereof is a thousand years of your reckoning (i.e. reckoning of our present world's time)." (Quran 32:5)

Above verses and hadith clearly shows the difference of progression in time through seven firmaments. It takes 500 years to reach from earth to boundries of duniya. Then, the heaven surrounding the duniya is 500 years thick, so it takes 1000 years of our time for something to reach the highest point of creation at the highest speed possible for us in Duniya (not planet earth but the lowest reality).

"The angels and the Rûh [Jibrael (Gabriel)] ascend to Him in a Day the measure whereof is fifty thousand years,..." (Quran 70:4)

"Allaah passes judgement between His slaves on a Day the length of which will be “like fifty thousand years”, ..." (Saheeh Muslim)

In the above verse and hadith, Allah is revealing the length of the day of judgment when sun will be overthrown, mening lower reality will cease to exist, and the progression of time will change.

One can go on for hours on the knowledge in Quran on time, but let's move on to the next point. So, we know that there are different time progression at different levels of creation. So, there must be a highest place where progression stops. Naturally that exist outside the boundaries of creation or close to it, known as SidratulMuntaha (Lote tree of the extreme limit).

"It is na on the authority of Abdullah (b. Umar) that when the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) was taken for the Night journey, he was taken to Sidrat-ul-Muntaha, which is situated on the sixth heaven, where terminates everything that ascends from the earth and is held there, and where terminates every- thing that descends from above it and is held there. (It is with reference to this that) Allah said:” When that which covers covered the lote-tree” (al-Qur’an, Iiii. 16). He (the narrator) said: (It was) gold moths." (Saheeh Muslim)
During the ascention of our Prophet (PBUH) reached that tree which is the edge of all creation.

"During the night of Isra' and Mi`raj, the Prophet was taken up to a point where he heard the screeching of the Pens (writing the divine Decree)."(Shaykh Muhammad `Alawi al-Malaki)

When he reached there he heard the screeching of the pen writing the decree (fate of all creation)

"The first thing which Allah created was the pen. Then, He said to it: Write. It asked: My Lord, what should I write? He said: Write the proportions of all things up until the Hour." (Ahmad, At-Tirmidhi)

"The pens have been lifted, and the tablets have dried." (At-Tirmidhi)

From above ahadith it is clear that Allah created the Pen, and the Pen wrote everything that has to happen, and then stopped, and then the creation was created. So, if the pen(s) stopped writting, how can Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) heard it writing that decree just 1430 years ago.
So, lets put all our knowledge together. Time slows as you travel towards the end of the creation, and does not exist beyond the Lote tree, and The decree was still being written close to the limits. It is only logical that Time doesn't exist or very very slow in some part of the creation. Furthermore, Hell and Paradise exist in those part of the creation, and so Angels, and so The Pen. What Prophet (PBUH) may have seen was the act that started along time and still cotinues.

In fact, our reality exists like a bubble which is progressing from begining to end. Angels enter this bubble at different point in time and space as Allah commands them.

For example, Aslam and Salman are sleeping in two rooms in the same house, and die in an explosion at the same time. Angel of death will enter at January 5, 2010 1:10:01 PM at Aslam's room and take his soul, then re-enter at the same exact time but different space (location) and take Salman's soul. If we can see both death happening at the same time, we will see them happening simultaneously, but in reality (true reality) Angel took Aslam's first then Salman's.


2) How was Mohammad (PBUH) able to see people in Hell and Paradise, when no one has entered yet?

During the asecention of our Prophet (PBUH) visited Hell and Paradise, and saw humans there. One thing to note is that NO human will enter the Hell or Paradise untill the day of Qiyamah (last day), so it seems impossible for our Prophet (PBUH) to see us in there. In fact, it may be possible, if the Hell and Paradise exist outside this reality and time bubble, Judgment day has already happened, and we all entered the appropriate last abode. However, in this world, we still experiencing the time captured in the bubble.

In other words, if our entering into Jannah or Jahanam follows in time progression after this world ends, then the after life will become the part of time progression, and time concept will extend to afterlife, which is highly unlikely.

3) How was Mohammad (PBUH) traveled to seventh heaven and beyond in one night?

So, when Rasool Allah (PBUH) traveled through the staircase of spirits, he crossed the boundries of time bubble, where all of us are existing after Qayamah in Hell and Paradise, and Pen writting at the same time (using it losely). When he returned, Angels brough him back to the same point in time then he departed, becuase remember he spent some time in Jerusalem.

"They asked about this, when the Prophet came back from Miraj. they asked, Where was he? His wife said that he was sleeping in the bed next to her. He went on Miraj and came back. The place he was lying was still warm, she said, when he came back." (Cliamed to be authenticated, but I couldn't find the reference)

There are other reports that the journey took one third of the night. Only Allah knows, which report is true. One thing for sure that Isra was in this world so time was passing, but Miraj was outside the bubble of time, so time didn't pass.

4) How long would we be in afterlife?

Regarding the question on how long we will live in Hell and Paradise. There is no progression of time there, so we will live there until Allah decides to destroy us from existence.

In truth, Prophet (PBUH) hearing the footsteps of Bilal, or knowing about the future generation is not very difficult for Angels, if Allah wills. We all exist here in this bubble whose worth is less than a wing of Mosquito, and when Allah promises that not even an atom worth of deed will be forgotten, it makes sense, because Angels can retreive that by entering this bubble at any point in time and space, if they haven't been recorded already.

This concept of time explains many of the mysteries that we struggle with, but it is an opinion. Please don't hesitate to follow up on this.

Just a Thinker
Adnan Jumani